Love Island winner criticizes All Stars for recycling old contestants

Love Island Star Speaks Out Against All Stars

Former Love Island champion Cara De La Hoyde has criticized the show's All Stars edition, arguing that constantly bringing back past contestants undermines the show's original appeal.

“You can’t keep bringing people back,” Cara said, sharing her thoughts on the show's recent spin-off.

Concerns About Show’s Direction

Cara, who won Love Island in 2016 with Nathan Massey, believes that All Stars should focus on fresh faces rather than familiar personalities. She expressed that too many returns may dilute the excitement and unpredictability that made the show popular.

She added that viewers tune in to see new relationships and dynamics, not the same compelling figures being recycled for ratings.

Audience Reaction

Fans appear divided. Some agree with Cara, saying they miss the discovery of new personalities, while others enjoy seeing their favorite Islanders again. Despite the debate, the All Stars series continues to attract significant attention and discussion online.


Author’s summary: Cara De La Hoyde criticized Love Island: All Stars for recycling former contestants, claiming it weakens the show’s freshness and original charm.

more

The Sun The Sun — 2025-11-24

More News