'Punished before conviction': Is this new welfare law a national shame?

Government's Welfare Cuts and Indigenous Australians

Just two years after the Voice referendum's dramatic failure, the Federal Government appears poised to severely impact Indigenous Australians. Critics say the government is "throwing Indigenous Australians under the bus" with little groundwork or preparation.

New Social Security Legislation

At the last minute, legislation has been introduced that would empower Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke to cancel social security payments if there is an outstanding warrant for a serious crime. This raises concerns about punishing individuals for alleged crimes they may not have committed.

Concerns over Punishment Before Conviction

"Punished for a crime you may not have committed."

Minister’s Explanation

Tanya Plibersek, Minister for Social Services, explained on morning television that any decision to cut benefits would require strong evidence and would take into account the needs of dependents. She said:

"After considering any dependents, making sure that we look after the dependents, that person can have their social security benefit cancelled the same way they would if they were waiting on remand to be tried for a serious crime."
Implications

This new approach could turn social security into a policing tool, raising serious ethical questions about welfare and justice.

Author’s summary: The government's rushed welfare legislation risks punishing people before conviction, with significant consequences for social justice and Indigenous communities.

more

The Canberra Times The Canberra Times — 2025-11-07