The Yankees' rotation, initially considered a strength, was impacted by injuries to Gerrit Cole and Luis Gil, affecting preseason expectations.
Despite starting the year with Marcus Stroman and Carlos Carrasco as their fifth starters, the rotation finished in the top 10 in ERA and WAR in 2025.
However, this success did not translate to the ALDS, where the Blue Jays struggled against Max Fried and Carlos Rodon, with Cam Schlittler being the only starter to register a quality start.
With Rodon starting the season on the injured list and Gerrit Cole not expected to be activated by Opening Day, questions arise about the need for additional starters.
The rotation finished inside the top 10 in ERA and WAR in 2025.
The team's performance in the ALDS raises concerns about the rotation's ability to perform under pressure.
Author's summary: Yankees face rotation concerns due to injuries.