Has Anthony Stolarz been good enough for the Leafs?

Has Anthony Stolarz Been Good Enough for the Leafs?

The Toronto Maple Leafs have experienced an inconsistent start this season following a division-winning year. Last season, one of their biggest strengths was goaltending.

This year, Leafs general manager Brad Treliving signed Anthony Stolarz to a four-year contract with an average annual value of $3.75 million. Stolarz came into the season after posting a .926 save percentage in 34 games, making the deal appear promising.

Challenges in Stolarz's Performance

Despite the fresh contract, there has been debate about Stolarz's play so far. A key factor affecting his performance is the team's defensive struggles. The Leafs have allowed Stolarz to face the ninth most high-danger shots among all NHL goalies.

It's clear a goalie cannot succeed easily when exposed to such a high number of quality scoring chances. Consequently, the Leafs have conceded the seventh most goals in the NHL this season, and Stolarz's save percentage has dropped to .895.

"With that number of high danger shots Stolarz has faced, it is no surprise that the Leafs have allowed the seventh most goals in the NHL, and Stolarz has a .895 save percentage."

Stolarz’s statistics indicate a decline compared to last year. He has recorded a -0.85 goals saved above average (GSAA), ranking 43rd in the league. This suggests more high-quality chances have gone in against him compared to his previous season.

Summary of Stolarz’s Current Situation

Author's Summary: Anthony Stolarz’s performance this season has declined amid defensive lapses, making it hard to replicate last year’s strong goaltending display.

more

Editor In Leaf Editor In Leaf — 2025-11-08