All Her Fault movie review & film summary (2025)

All Her Fault is an anxiety-driving thriller with abrupt twists reminiscent of sudden sinkholes and venomous snake pits. The story begins with Marissa (Sarah Snook) arriving at a playdate to pick up her son, Milo (Duke McCloud), only to find the host, Jenny (Dakota Fanning), unresponsive and confused.

The tension only escalates from that moment, keeping viewers on edge. Adapted from Andrea Mara's novel, the eight-episode series plunges viewers into a relentless storm of suspicion and blame from the instant Milo goes missing.

Plot and Characters

Every error, accusing glance, and suspicion is portrayed in intense detail, inviting the audience to scream at the screen. Doubt creeps into each character’s intentions, including Marissa’s husband Peter (Jake Lacy), the other mothers, nannies (Kartiah Vergara, Sophia Lillis), family members (Abby Elliott, Daniel Monks), and the business partner (Jay Ellis). Everyone is shrouded in mystery, suggesting guilt without clear answers.

Narrative Style

Through flashbacks spanning a decade, the story threads gradually intertwine, yet these glimpses sometimes conceal more than they reveal. This cat-and-mouse storytelling dynamic keeps the audience captivated.

“All Her Fault” is an anxiety-inducing thriller with the sudden drops of a sinkhole and the venomous twists of a snake pit.

“Every mistake, every glare of blame, and suspicion is rendered in vivid detail. You’re supposed to scream at the screen, and you probably will.”

“Everyone is draped in shadows, so we’re not sure who did what, but we’re sure they’ve all done something wrong.”

Author’s summary: This psychological thriller excels in crafting suspense through complex characters and an unsettling narrative that keeps viewers guessing until the very end.

Roger Ebert — 2025-11-05